.
Feedback

Supes Remain Hopeful about Grady Ranch

Supervisor Steve Kinsey believes the "Death Star is dimming." Lucas Valley Estates neighbors take the heat.

Despite Skywalker Properties’ insistence that , the Marin Board of Supervisors remain hopeful that they will change their mind.

“From my view the Death Star is dimming,” Supervisor Steve Kinsey said Tuesday. “We will approve this project when it comes back.”

Supporters of the Grady Ranch project, filmmaker George Lucas’s proposed 269,000-square-foot digital studio, filled the board’s Tuesday meeting. Their public comments lasted over an hour.


Bill Grady, who’s family is the namesake for the ranch, is one of many who are hopeful that Grady Ranch will be constructed. “As a family we would just love to have our names associated with this project, but in a positive way,” he said.

The Marin Economic Forum estimates that the withdrawal will result in a total of $216 million in lost revenue. The project would've created 690 jobs, with 463 jobs for the two-year construction phase alone.

Lucas Valley neighbor Ron Litvin said he was horrified when he heard the Skywalker Properties announcement. “I realize there will be some negatives, but there’s aways some negatives,” he said.

, but claiming that the plan failed to meet environmental standards and was inconsistent with zoning requirements in the largely residential area.

Supervisors to review the legal concerns regarding regulations with local and other agencies, when LucasFilm shocked the county last week and

"We have several opportunities to build the production stages in communities that see us as a creative asset, not as an evil empire, and if we are to stay on schedule we must act on those opportunities," their statement said.

Shere Ripley is a Lucas Valley Estates resident. Unlike several of her neighbors, she wants Lucas to stay in Marin to create jobs for kids who will grow and want to work in the county. “We need it for our kids. We need it for our future,” she said.

Hostility is swirling toward the Lucas Valley Estates neighbors who opposed the project since the Skywalker Properties' announcement. One neighbor, who wished to remain nameless, said several neighbors had received threats.

"Cannot say enough about the self centered, short sighted, clueless people of the Lucas Valley Estates? Now possibly the most hated people in Marin." Deanna Davisson commented via Facebook on a Marin Independent Journal article about the appeal.

The Lucas Valley Estates Homeowners Association issued a statement after the withdraw was announced that said "There were clearly many factors involved in making this decision. We are sure that it was made with consideration for what is best for Lucasfilm."

Since the announcement, the county launched a website urging supporters to write letters to Skywalker Properties. Despite the influx of support, LucasFilm Director of Communications Lynne Hale told reporters last week that the company would not reconsider and had to move on.

But Supervisor Judy Arnold remains optimistic. “Reconsider, come back, let’s finish the Grady Ranch project,” she said.

Want to write a letter supporting Grady Ranch? Go here for details.

Likes Facts April 17, 2012 at 05:23 pm
The poll question is wierd -- I sympathize with their frustration, but I don't think they were right in believing that the community is opposed to their project. The overwhelming majority wants them here and to reconsider. So voted no, they weren't right, because Grady Ranch is the right place for them to be -- please reconsider!
A more useful poll question would be to gauge the community support for them to reconsider.
Nicole Ely (Editor) April 17, 2012 at 05:30 pm
Good catch. It was the wrong poll. Fixed now!
George Morris April 17, 2012 at 06:39 pm
George Lucas is irreplaceable. He is a wondeful steward of the land. His values are conssistent with Marinites who wish to preserve open space and he has the financial capacity to make it happen
George Morris
Rev. Daniel Christian April 17, 2012 at 07:58 pm
The Grady Ranch opponents are an embarrassment to Marin. The citizens of Marin know, and hopefully the George Lucas people can see that the opponents are nothing more than a "tyranny of the minority- or in this case-tyranny of the few" and the project can prevail.
Kevin April 17, 2012 at 09:06 pm
The problem is that the US gov is involved now and they move too slow for George to reconsider. Thanks Lucas Valley Estates! I hope someone doesn't organize a horn honking campaign on Lucas Valley rd!
Marley Sheperd April 17, 2012 at 09:10 pm
Is it time for Marin to outgrow the "NIMBY" point of view ?.George Lucas has put much needed money and time in the projects here in Marin ,improvements in the countryside (open space),a compound which is hidden from street views,redevelopments of property's with taste and style keeping Marin's charm .Time and energy has gone into the planning of this new project ,short cuts I would guess have not been taken, not their style .It's time to stop moving the "goal" post and live with the beauty, both man made and nature has given us . If the Lucas crew moves on to develop another area ... Marin will be the loser . Money can be spent anywhere ,other places would benefit from the thoughtful thinking crew of the Lucas group .
Marley
Karen Dionne April 18, 2012 at 11:31 am
It's a downright shame LucasFilm was run off. People in high places need to step in and show George Lucas that this can be fixed. The government definitely moves at a snail's pace, so unless someone can light a fire underneath them, the situation is most likely hopeless. Although I'm still hoping otherwise!
Tired April 18, 2012 at 02:03 pm
First it was the Grateful dead music venue, then the Local Baseball team effort, then affordable housing, and now this...Watch out NIMBYISM is coming to a neihgborhood near you!
Michael April 19, 2012 at 11:37 am
Lucas' ventures are not smoke billowing polluting factories are they? Take a look at what HE just did on the Miracle Mile in San Anselmo. He cleaned up decrepit part of the median and it is now beautiful. How is his involvement in our community bad for us? A few selfish people trying to inflict THEIR narrow view of how life should be for all of us in Marin. We need strong leadership which apparently we do not have. The current Board needs to go as they have been growing long roots. Do we want or need career politicians? They blew this one by focusing on other non important issues instead of this good one. Heck Susan Adams is busy looking for her next government job in congress. Is she really paying attention to her current responsibilities?
Kid Adam April 19, 2012 at 12:30 pm
just another example of "me-rin" some of you are a joke. I haven't lives here as long as most but get over yourselves. Name one other county in the country that would turn down these opportunities. Shame on you "ME"rin
William Noble April 19, 2012 at 04:07 pm
I heard the head of the Lucas Valley Estates Homeowners Association on Michael Krazny's KQED program. I'm not sure I've ever heard a community activist, of any stripe, who lied so glibly and continuously. I was particularly astonished at her we didn't do anything, "We were just bystanders" remark.
gary April 19, 2012 at 04:52 pm
You can thank Carolyn Lenert and her ilk. Ironically, she is a realtor who could have sold a few Marin homes to the 900 employees, ya think?
http://www.marinij.com/business/ci_20417866/lucas-supporters-marin-supervisors-urge-filmmaker-reconsider-bailing "Carolyn Lenert, head of the North San Rafael Coalition of Residents and a vocal opponent of the Lucas plan, was alone in standing to say a contrary word about the program. She contended Lucas Valley Estates "has not threatened suit," claimed neighbors were "never notified" about the project, and urged "due process ... a level playing field" and "no special treatment." Lenert drew boos and hisses from a partisan crowd solidly in favor of the filmmaker. Several residents of Lucas Valley Estates said the homeowners group did not reflect the feelings of the neighborhood, with one saying a defunct organization was revived by a handful of Lucas foes and another saying the association was merely a few "vociferous opponents."" But it looks like Lucas' decision is final. Such a shame. Shame on you, Lenert - way to go. http://www.marinij.com/business/ci_20426046/lucasfilm-marin-our-decision-is-final
kiki April 19, 2012 at 05:33 pm
the way things are going, marin is a nice place to visit but i'm not so sure about living here any more.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from San Rafael Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Withdraw the Civic Center Priority Development Area
Ciel Niesen-Love June 15, 2013 at 07:41 pm
I, for one, am glad they're finally doing this. I have watched for years as Marin has ignored theRead More population growth that has affected us all. Not wanting to put in a commuter train, until the traffic lining the freeway is backed up into another county in the morning, is just one example of this. Then we have the fact that most of the children that my husband and I went to school with in Terra Linda have had to move to other counties because we can't find affordable housing in this one. To top it all off, it seems that the ones who have blocked us from making the smaller additions throughout the county have been people directly involved in the real estate industry, or just local home owners so worried about the value of their homes going down, that they fail to see the larger picture. So here we are, about to make a stride in alleviating the problem, and instead of rallying to make our communities better, we're trying to make it more difficult for the people who live and grew up here to still remain close to their families, not to mention the disabled adults and large elderly population in this county that are in need of this, as well. Some of the teacher's who work in this district have to commute in that traffic every morning, because they can't afford to live in this county, either. It's a sad commentary on where our priorities are when we can't support each other as a community.
John Parulis June 17, 2013 at 11:44 am
Ciel......we're talking big box freeway developments that will add tremendous traffic, schooling andRead More tax burdens to our community. Your ideas about population growth in Marin are off.
Ciel Niesen-Love June 17, 2013 at 02:49 pm
I know the population in Marin is 1% per year, but why do you think that is? People are livingRead More longer and our children are the healthiest in the country. I'll tell you why. It's because the children grow up and move out of the county, because it's not affordable. Here is an example of my latest thoughts on the matter: As the member of a Native American tribe, I have to say that I really resent being told where I should be able to live by an immigrant such as Richard Hall. I believe that roots are important and even if the growth rate has been 1%, it's only because most of the people who have grown up here can not afford to live here and move away. The elderly who make up a large percent of the population here are living longer due to medical advances and who do you suppose will take care of them? People such as myself and for not nearly enough money to live here. So what do you propose? You think that I should move to the East Bay or the North Bay and commute? Well, due to the lack of transportation support, that sound so lovely, let me tell you. Also, the children in Marin are the healthiest in the country according to a recent article I've read. Lower children death rates and such, so who is supposed to teach them and provide care for them and for not enough money to live here? Well, many teachers and care providers that I know that have to commute or live multiple roommates. You have successfully produced a community that only grows 1% per year. Congratulations. Through your grassroots efforts of blocking housing and transportation for years and claiming they don't live up to your standards, meanwhile not providing any pushes for what you might actually feel is smarter you have shut out your county's own children and hard working patriots. So, we can work for minimum wage taking care of your elderly, your children, your precious houses and cars, but God forbid, our children go to school with yours, or that you might actually have to bump into us at the supermarket and say "hi". This is the attitude which had prevailed here and I and many other people I talk to in my neighborhood and that I've grown up with are sick of it. Also, I'd like to point out that we all work hard, and the opportunity to work has been at the help of all of the people in our communities who have helped rear us. Teachers, nurses, doctors, firemen, policeman, babysitters, and many more. Just because some jobs like teaching or care giving don't provide with as much money, doesn't make them less important. In fact, my grandma used to tell me it "God's work". It takes a village to raise your children and it took a village to raise you all.