American Academy of Pediatrics Changes Stance on Circumcision

Even as the circumcision rate for newborn baby boys in the United States reaches its lowest level in decades, the American Academy of Pediatrics reported Monday that the health benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks.

It’s the first time that the influential medical group has updated its circumcision policy since 1999. The academy said that medical insurers should cover the procedure.  

A review of medical literature published Monday in the journal "Pediatrics" finds that circumcision may protect heterosexual men against HIV infection. The policy shift comes as circumcision becomes a charged political topic from the Bay Area to Germany, where a court ruled in June that circumcision is illegal. Jewish groups are asking the German government to pass legislation that protects the practice. 

In Marin, members of Bay Area Intactivists recently demonstrated against the practice at 68 Mitchell Blvd. According to the Marin Independent Journal,the protesters held signs the showed a screaming baby undergoing the procedure while others had the words "Sex criminals for hire — inquire within."

"I think circumcision is one of the most grotesque forms of sexual and physical abuse you can inflict on someone," Jonathan Conte told the Marin IJ. "If I were to hold down my neighbor against his will, restrain him or her and cut away at their genitals, I would be arrested."

The academy's position does not endorse circumcision, but suggests that it should be an option available to parents, according to an article in the New York Times. 

According to a federal study of circumcisions performed in community hospitals published in February, there were 1.2 million hospital circumcisions in 2009. California counts one of the lowest circumcision rates in the country with 22 percent. 

Last year, Berkeley's Peace and Justice Commission passed a resolution condemning a comic book character created by an anti-circumcision group called Foreskin Man that many deemed to be anti-Semitic. 

What do you think? Should circumcision should be banned, or should parents be allowed to have the choice, as the American Academy of Pediatrics suggests? 

Want to stay in the loop about eveything happening in San Rafael? Sign up for our newsletter or become a fan on Facebook.

Here's what else is happening on San Rafael Patch:

"Like" us on Facebook | Follow us Twitter | Get "Patched" in with our newsletter | Start a blog